Re: Patriarchy: Re: What Matriarchy?
Bryant (mycol1@unm.edu)
9 Sep 1996 09:51:31 -0600
In article <50voh1$1b9@dfw-ixnews2.ix.netcom.com>,
Mary Beth Williams <mbwillia@ix.netcom.com> wrote:
>
>I'm sorry, Bryant, if I offended you through the use of a *stock
>phrase* with which I assume most culturally literate Americans are
>familiar.
Heh. Perhaps it is I who should clarify.
I understood your use of a tired phrase to make an unfair point about straw
man arguments. I responded with humor. The point (which you took
pains to erase in your followup) is that you spoke for a group that
indeed does commit the naturalistic fallacy on a regular basis, when
arguing with folks like me who think that evolutionary science might shed
light on the study of an evolved species of biological organism (humans).
That was hardly a glaring example of straw-manning on my part, as you
suggested with the "when did you stop beating your wife" business.
I was hoping you might respond to the substance of the post instead of
the joke which was post-scripted to it.
>I promise in the future to simplify my level of discourse so
>as not to offend you.
Jeesh, grow up. It was a joke. You marxist postmodernist
non-Amerinds really *are* a humorless lot.
>MB Williams
>Dept. of Anthro., UMass-Amherst
Bryant
|